Govt to seek review of SC order on judges as CICs - Hindustan Times:
One of the casualty of bad governance in India has been the institutional balance created by the Constitution. Appointment, including the appointment of judges, is legitimately function of the Executive, but the Govt's acts of omissions & commissions in appointments raised doubts about the intentions and ability of the Govt to put right people in right places. The ideas of committed bureaucracy and committed judiciary, with a captive media, lowered people's faith in Institutions. In this backdrop the Supreme Court stepped in and claimed for itself a larger role in the appointment of judges. People's distrust of the Govt made the SC's task easy. After tasting blood the Supreme Court wants for itself and the judicial fraternity more & more power. This can't and shouldn't be allowed. The Court should step in only when the Govt fails to put right people in right place.
Wednesday, September 26, 2012
Tuesday, September 25, 2012
The Irrelevance of Modern Political Science
The Irrelevance of Modern Political Science — The American Magazine:
If in the land of its birth Political Science( not politics/Rajneeti/ NeetiShastra/ RajDharm) is beginning to be thought as irrelevant, what about countries like India where no first hand or first rate work has been done in the discipline?
If in the land of its birth Political Science( not politics/Rajneeti/ NeetiShastra/ RajDharm) is beginning to be thought as irrelevant, what about countries like India where no first hand or first rate work has been done in the discipline?
The Weaker Sex - Sandra Tsing Loh
The Weaker Sex - Sandra Tsing Loh - The Atlantic:
Are we going to experience role reversal soon? The workplace is likely to be more feminine and housework more masculine.
Are we going to experience role reversal soon? The workplace is likely to be more feminine and housework more masculine.
Thursday, September 20, 2012
The Desirability of Bunds
Bunds, Gheraos, HallaBols are Indian contrivance for disrupting the rule of law and making democratic life miserable.Even though Bunds have not found entry in Wikipedia & dictionaries, they are very popular with Indian political parties. Why are Bunds called? What is the teleological explanation of a Bund? Through Bunds what do we try to achieve?Are Bunds a means to an end or an end in themselves? Are Bunds rational? These questions beg an urgent answer.
If I recollect correctly Bunds were first introduced in Indian polity by the Socialists and Communists. The then Kerala Governor Mr Vishwanathan rightly pointed out that to call Bund to protest against shortage of rice was meaningless as " Bunds do not produce rice." Let us see why are Bunds called? There may three main reasons : 1) to protest against a particular policy or policies of the govt.; 2) to protest against an event; and 3) to show the support of the people for the cause. For these purposes the political system provides for mechanism of political communication and feedback. Why don't the Bund-callers make use of these mechanisms? The Bund-callers wrongly believe that causing hardship to the common people will frighten the side against which the Bund has been called. In public affairs, particularly in a democracy, the argument of reason is more effective than a show of strength and argument of violence. Bunds achieve nothing, cause immense hardship to the people, particularly the patients, children, travelers and daily bread earners. For organizers of Bund calling for a Bund is not a means to an end, but an end in itself. It tramples the Fundamental Rights of others, it endangers our lives, it fosters indiscipline and an atmosphere of anarchy. The time has come when we should firmly say a big NO to Bunds.
If I recollect correctly Bunds were first introduced in Indian polity by the Socialists and Communists. The then Kerala Governor Mr Vishwanathan rightly pointed out that to call Bund to protest against shortage of rice was meaningless as " Bunds do not produce rice." Let us see why are Bunds called? There may three main reasons : 1) to protest against a particular policy or policies of the govt.; 2) to protest against an event; and 3) to show the support of the people for the cause. For these purposes the political system provides for mechanism of political communication and feedback. Why don't the Bund-callers make use of these mechanisms? The Bund-callers wrongly believe that causing hardship to the common people will frighten the side against which the Bund has been called. In public affairs, particularly in a democracy, the argument of reason is more effective than a show of strength and argument of violence. Bunds achieve nothing, cause immense hardship to the people, particularly the patients, children, travelers and daily bread earners. For organizers of Bund calling for a Bund is not a means to an end, but an end in itself. It tramples the Fundamental Rights of others, it endangers our lives, it fosters indiscipline and an atmosphere of anarchy. The time has come when we should firmly say a big NO to Bunds.
Tuesday, September 18, 2012
'Foolish and Backward Nation': A Self-Effacing Chinese Satire of America - The Atlantic
'Foolish and Backward Nation': A Self-Effacing Chinese Satire of America - The Atlantic
This satire, ostensibly of the USA, but actually of China, proves that the Chinese Govt is more tolerant of criticism than our own UPA. Had this been about India, the UPA would most certainly have banned it.
This satire, ostensibly of the USA, but actually of China, proves that the Chinese Govt is more tolerant of criticism than our own UPA. Had this been about India, the UPA would most certainly have banned it.
Monday, September 17, 2012
A disturbed history
A disturbed history | Cover Story | Times Crest:
A journalistic history of House Disruptions in India. Even in Nehru's days there were disruptions. That was not only Nehru era, but the era of single party polity. Nehru exercised immense influence not only over the members of his party, but on others as well. During Nehru era Indian polity was not so fractured. With conflictual and confrontationist politics replacing the earlier consensual and accommodative politics Parliament became more noisy and prone to disruptions.
A journalistic history of House Disruptions in India. Even in Nehru's days there were disruptions. That was not only Nehru era, but the era of single party polity. Nehru exercised immense influence not only over the members of his party, but on others as well. During Nehru era Indian polity was not so fractured. With conflictual and confrontationist politics replacing the earlier consensual and accommodative politics Parliament became more noisy and prone to disruptions.
Sunday, September 16, 2012
Islamism’s turning point
Islamism’s turning point - Salon.com:
After Hindutva we now have Islamism. Researchers on Muslim majority societies have found that there are variations in Islamic beliefs and practices. We believed that Islam was a monolith, but it is not so. It simply means that there are elements of pluralism in Islam also. If that is so it is better for the world and religious fundamentalists of all hues to realise this. The researchers have suggested that instead of Islam we should call it Islams.
After Hindutva we now have Islamism. Researchers on Muslim majority societies have found that there are variations in Islamic beliefs and practices. We believed that Islam was a monolith, but it is not so. It simply means that there are elements of pluralism in Islam also. If that is so it is better for the world and religious fundamentalists of all hues to realise this. The researchers have suggested that instead of Islam we should call it Islams.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)